The notebookInside the ranking system
Note 12 of 203 min read

How does Google detect spam?

Check Search Console for manual actions and indexing problems before assuming a ranking drop is a penalty.

Previously: What are Google ranking signals? Spam checks can also affect whether a page appears and where it ranks.

Worked example

Check the report before naming a penalty

These two problems need different actions.

An indexing instruction blocks the page

  1. URL Inspection

    Reports that a noindex instruction was detected.

  2. Inspect the page

    Confirm whether that instruction is intentional.

  3. Fix and recheck

    Remove an unintended noindex, then run a live test.

What to noticeThis is an access or indexing problem. Follow the reported reason rather than assuming a spam penalty.

Example diagnostic paths. A clean Manual Actions report does not rule out every automated spam effect.

Google uses automated spam detection, including SpamBrain, and manual actions to address pages and links that break its spam policies.

The model includes stored information about spam and other risks. The exact effect of Google’s private checks is unknown. A relevant page can still have a spam problem that affects whether it appears or where it ranks.

What gets checked

Examples include link schemes, hacked pages and cloaking. Cloaking means showing search engines different content from what visitors see. Google’s policies also cover content created at scale primarily to manipulate rankings.

A link count alone cannot tell you whether backlinks are useful or legitimate. Open the linking pages and check why the links are there.

Check indexing problems first

In Search Console, inspect the affected URL. A noindex instruction can keep a page out of search. A server error can stop Google fetching it. A canonical tag can identify another URL as the main version.

Those problems need fixing, but they don’t mean Google applied a spam penalty.

Investigate a ranking drop

Open the Manual Actions report in Search Console. If it reports an action, read the affected pages and the reason given.

Then check the Performance report for the exact page and queries that lost rankings or clicks. Did the drop affect one page or several? Did you change the page, its URL or its links? Did the competing results change?

A page falling for two days doesn’t establish a penalty. Save the dates and findings before deciding what to change.

A relevant website can link to your page because it helps its readers. Look for that connection when pursuing backlinks.

Keep your pages accessible and their subjects clear. When a problem appears, use the reports and the affected URLs to investigate it.

Keep this in your notes

Check Search Console for manual actions and indexing problems before assuming a ranking drop is a penalty.

The next question

Pages that can appear for a query still have to compete with other relevant pages. Continue with how does google rank websites?